Proudly afflicting the comfortable [and collecting shiny things] since March 2003

Send Magpie an email!

RSS Feeds
Click button to subscribe.

Subscribe to Magpie via Feedburner  Magpie's RSS feed via Bloglines
Add to Netvibes

Need a password?
Click the button!

Bypass 'free' registration!

Cost of the Iraq War [US$]
(JavaScript Error)
[Find out more here]

Hooded Liberty

Alas, a Blog
Back to Iraq
Baghdad Burning
Bitch Ph.D.
blac (k) ademic
Blog Report
Blogs by Women
Burnt Orange Report
Confined Space
Daily Kos
Dangereuse trilingue
Echidne of the Snakes
Effect Measure
Eschaton (Atrios)
Follow Me Here
The Housing Bubble New!
I Blame the Patriarchy
Juan Cole/Informed Comment
Kicking Ass
The King's Blog
The Krile Files
Left Coaster
Loaded Orygun
Making Light
Marian's Blog
Muslim Wake Up! Blog
My Left Wing
The NewsHoggers
Null Device
Pacific Views
The Panda's Thumb
Peking Duck
Pinko Feminist Hellcat
Political Animal
Reality-Based Community
Riba Rambles
The Rittenhouse Review
Road to Surfdom
The Sideshow
The Silence of Our Friends New!
Sisyphus Shrugged
Suburban Guerrilla
Talk Left
Talking Points Memo
This Modern World
The Unapologetic Mexican New!
War and Piece
wood s lot

Body and Soul
General Glut's Globlog
Respectful of Otters

Image by Propaganda Remix Project. Click to see more.

Magpie is a former journalist, attempted historian [No, you can't ask how her thesis is going], and full-time corvid of the lesbian persuasion. She keeps herself in birdseed by writing those bad computer manuals that you toss out without bothering to read them. She also blogs too much when she's not on deadline, both here and at Pacific Views.

Magpie roosts in Portland, Oregon, where she annoys her housemates (as well as her cats Medea, Whiskers, and Jane Doe) by attempting to play Irish music on the fiddle and concertina.

If you like, you can send Magpie an email!

Ask Technorati.
Or ask WhoLinksToMe.

Politics Blog Top Sites

Progressive Women's Blog Ring

Join | List |
Previous | Next | Random |
Previous 5 | Next 5 |
Skip Previous | Skip Next

Powered by RingSurf

Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons License.

Check to open links in new windows. Uncheck to see comments.

Friday, December 2, 2005

How many important facts can you ignore in a news story?

Damn near all of them, if you're the AP and CNN.

Online, CNN has been running an AP story about how New Jersey governor-elect Jon Corzine may have decided to appoint state senator Nia Gill to fill out his unexpired term in the US Senate when he moves from Washington to Trenton.

CNN screen shot

Screen shot from

As you can see from the headline and photo, Gill is both black and a woman — both of which are significant reasons to appoint a person to the US Senate, given how overwhelmingly white and male that body is compared to the US population as a whole.

However, being just black and a woman shouldn't in itself be a reason to get the job, we'd think. And when we read the story to find out about Gill's other qualifications, what we discover is that she's a lawyer — and if we read way down to the very bottom of the story, we also find out that she served in the New Jersey House. Not irrelevant qualifications, but certainly far from a good picture of Gill's experience, wouldn't you say?

On the other hand, the AP story does go to the trouble to tell us the following, not too far from the top:

Political analysts say that by choosing Gill, Corzine would be seen as rewarding a faithful base that turned out for him on Election Day — and possibly sending a signal about his higher political aspirations.

So, as far as the AP bothers to tell us, Gill's main qualifications for being a senator are that her appointment would pay off one of Corzine's political debts, and maybe give him a leg up if he wants to run for president. Right in line with the concept of 'reverse discrimination,' the story is implicitly telling us that Gill will get the job because she's black — not because she's qualified.

What's really annoying here is that it would have taken no time at all to come up with a good list of reasons why Gill is qualified for the US Senate. [It took us about 30 seconds of Googling.] Here are just a few of them:
  • Gill was Democratic Whip for three of the four terms she served in the New Jersey House.
  • In 1997, she helped lead the opposition to an attempt to override the governor's veto of a law that would have banned third trimester abortions [so called 'partial birth abortion].
  • She was a sponsor of a recently enacted state law that bars public officals from depriving anyone of their civil rights, including 'racial profiling' done by law enforcement.
  • Gill sponsored a bill providing a $3000 tax deduction for families that provide home care to an elderly family member, and another to abolish the state's death penalty.
  • She currently serves on the state senate's Judiciary Committee, which — as with the US Senate — is one of the body's most powerful committees.

From that list, it's pretty obvious that Gill has excellent credentials as a progressive legislator and — from her service as House minority whip and on the Senate Judiciary committee — is highly regarded by her Democratic colleagues in the legislature. And we figured all of this out from info at the very first place we looked.

But the AP didn't see fit to look into Gill's background. Or, if they did look, they didn't think it important enough to include any of it in their story. And no flags went up when the CNN editor saw the story either — they just passed it on without adding any information about Gill's background. Instead, both AP and CNN were content to leave readers with the impression that, if Gill is appointed to the US Senate, the only thing involved is a political payoff that hinged on her ethnicity.

We have difficulty believing that this story would have looked the same had Nia Gill, a black woman, been Neil Gill, a white man.

Can we say 'racism'?

Thanks to Glenn Greenwald for pointing us to the CNN story. His excellent post on this topic can be found here.

[Post changed to correct misattribution to CNN only.]

| | Posted by Magpie at 6:24 PM | Get permalink

Liar, liar, pants on fire!


Mail & Guardian [S. Africa]
BBC News
CBC News
Agence France Presse
Associated Press
Inter Press Service
Watching America
International Herald Tribune
Guardian (UK)
Independent (UK)
USA Today
NY Times (US)
Washington Post (US)
McClatchy Washington Bureau (US)
Boston Globe (US)
LA Times (US)
Globe & Mail (Canada)
Toronto Star (Canada)
Sydney Morning Herald (Australia)
Mail & Guardian (South Africa)
Al-Ahram (Egypt)
Daily Star (Lebanon)
Haaretz (Israel)
Hindustan Times (India)
Japan Times (Japan)
Asia Times (Hong Kong)
New Scientist News
Paper Chase

Molly Ivins
CJR Daily
Women's eNews
Raw Story
The Gadflyer
Working for Change
Common Dreams
Democracy Now!
American Microphone
The Revealer
Editor & Publisher
Economic Policy Institute
Center for American Progress
The Memory Hole

Irish-American fiddler Liz Carroll

Céilí House (RTE Radio)
The Irish Fiddle
Fiddler Magazine
Concertina Library
A Guide to the Irish Flute
Chiff & Fipple
Irtrad-l Archives
Comhaltas Ceoltoiri Eireann
BBC Virtual Session
JC's ABC Tune Finder

Propaganda Remix Project
Ask a Ninja
Boiling Point
Cat and Girl
Dykes to Watch Out For
Library of Congress
American Heritage Dictionary
Dictonary of Newfoundland English
American's Guide to Canada
Digital History of the San Fernando Valley
Blithe House Quarterly
Astronomy Pic of the Day
Earth Science Picture of the Day
Asia Grace
Gaelic Curse Engine
Old Dinosaur Books